Skip to content

Instantly share code, notes, and snippets.

@torvalds
Last active July 27, 2025 13:15
Show Gist options
  • Save torvalds/6faadce34c56d53b2d5352da0c3cd093 to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Save torvalds/6faadce34c56d53b2d5352da0c3cd093 to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Not involved with any fishy crypto fishy business
I'm told that there are people claiming to "tokenize" my git repositories with my approval.
I just want to clarify that that is not the case. I do not believe in monetizing my repositories.
If you believe crypto-currencies are anything but a scam, I have a bridge to sell you.
But I'm not selling source code.
@LauraDoesProgramming
Copy link

This is ridiculous, I thought NFTs died out 3 years ago, and now they're scamming out Github repos?

This whole thing belongs to https://www.web3isgoinggreat.com
If someone made an crypto pump'n'dump out of my repos (If I had any), I'd seek legal counseling, probably already happened with someone else, since the scammers now seek permission by spamming spammy spammail

Thank you Linus for providing a disclaimer, and if you, dear reader, got an offer by them: don't fall for it, it's more likely to get the 5'000'000€ from the Nigerian prince you got in an email from 2008

@LauraDoesProgramming
Copy link

LauraDoesProgramming commented Jun 15, 2025

This whole thing belongs to https://www.web3isgoinggreat.com/

I have made a suggestion here: molly/web3-is-going-great#1243

@bap2pecs
Copy link

To close off this chapter, we’ve now completed full refunds for everyone who participated, and returned ~25k SOL to ~9k users (https://x.com/gitfish/status/1934094603998916932)

All transactions are recorded and auditable: https://github.com/gitfishdev/linux-refund/tree/main/data

The $LINUX token is officially retired.

@rayanmargham
Copy link

This is ridiculous, I thought NFTs died out 3 years ago, and now they're scamming out Github repos?

This whole thing belongs to https://www.web3isgoinggreat.com If someone made an crypto pump'n'dump out of my repos (If I had any), I'd seek legal counseling, probably already happened with someone else, since the scammers now seek permission by spamming spammy spammail

Thank you Linus for providing a disclaimer, and if you, dear reader, got an offer by them: don't fall for it, it's more likely to get the 5'000'000€ from the Nigerian prince you got in an email from 2008

hi laura @torvalds be best friends with my best friend laura

@tomviolin
Copy link

tomviolin commented Jun 15, 2025 via email

@h8d13
Copy link

h8d13 commented Jun 15, 2025

We randomly chose the hottest subject around for our first scam project. Using other's work and image for visibility and now refunding users in an poor attempt at recovery.

Adding a layer of shit to something that already exist (and works well) is still shit. About sponsor profiles not being accepted in countries unsupported is another question (and one for Shitcrosoft).

@MistyPigeon
Copy link

Ok this has escalated and surely we just have to stop this however Linus T. (@torvalds) wants and look at the GitFish website and press the info button (This is only for Chrome and Google users) you will see a warn pop-up.Surely all GitFish tokens are virtual malware and GitFish is probably phishing people.If i was Linus T. (@torvalds) i would stop this aswell so @tomviolin and the rest lets stop debating,I have been getting notifs from this gist in the night for SO LONG and i on average now have 5 hours of sleep,Ignore the crashout but lets touch grass for a day,the LINUX token was just a start-up for more controversy,Infact Linus T. (@torvalds) would prob say smth like this
Screenshot 2025-06-18 115231
aswell,And @MuntashirAkon i agree with you.

@AlleyPally
Copy link

Woe, plague be upon all NFT bros.

@tema5002
Copy link

indeed open source projects need commercial support
but what the hell is wrong with you you launch token for some project without owner's consent
there are better ways to monetize stuff that have trust from people

@iYonga
Copy link

iYonga commented Jul 2, 2025

@treuks
Copy link

treuks commented Jul 4, 2025

HEY! I think you misunderstood me. I was implying all cryptos are scams/mlm schemes.

@heyjoeway
Copy link

BASED.

@xinbenlv
Copy link

xinbenlv commented Jul 4, 2025

I didn't even know that someone "tokenize" github repo. We at https://namefi.io tokenize domains even so it will require domain ownership be put in the control of our system in order tokenize it. Tokenizing non-onchain assets always involves putting the right of control into a "vault". Any other approach that seems to issue token out of thin-air is pure scam.

@jxu
Copy link

jxu commented Jul 5, 2025

GitPhish shitcoins

@lash0000
Copy link

lash0000 commented Jul 9, 2025

when this project became buy/sell???

image

image

@Sirvaude
Copy link

Sirvaude commented Jul 9, 2025

If you believe crypto-currencies are anything but a scam, I have a bridge to sell you.

This is just pure ignorance, lol, you can skip crypto if you want, and probably 90% of the garbage projects are scam, but claiming anything is scam, is just raw ignorance.

@wiseaidev
Copy link

wiseaidev commented Jul 9, 2025

@wiseaidev
I am very confused on how you think Microsoft is against Linux? They just (somewhat) open sourced WSL. Not only that, there are plenty of projects that you can only use on Linux that have GitHub sponsors. I don't understand this.

See Microsoft's anti-linux propaganda and tell me.

@wiseaidev I have actually, however Microsoft has been becoming increasingly more open. Nothing will happen to you. Especally from GitHub where they don't really care what code you post. Its stupidly simple. I will be more than happy to show you github repos that have the sponsors enabled.

I say this as a humble bumble coding nerd with no hate for Microsoft. I actually love C# and .NYET, they got me into programming ever since High School. But let's be honest: Microsoft makes some of the most bloated software known to mankind. Open-sourcing stuff is nice et al, but doesn't fix the fact they keep dropping useless software like Cortana and Copilot. These tools eat up resources, slow down machines, and solve problems that don't exist. It's like they're trying to reinvent the wheel, except the wheel now needs 32GB of RAM and a Microsoft account just to spin.

@wiseaidev
Copy link

If you believe crypto-currencies are anything but a scam, I have a bridge to sell you.

This is just pure ignorance, lol, you can skip crypto if you want, and probably 90% of the garbage projects are scam, but claiming anything is scam, is just raw ignorance.

Yo, that's straight-up disrespect to our godfather. Without his work, you wouldn't even have the tech to post this comment. He's not just right, he's been calling it like it is. The real problem in crypto is perception. The tech itself is solid, but people turn it into a scam by chasing quick money, pumping hype coins, and selling false promises. Linus isn't necessarily against crypto itself, he's more likely against the circus around it.

@mehedihassan0
Copy link

mehedihassan0 commented Jul 9, 2025

i think he said crypto is scam because crypto looks like decentralized but its not that hard to control , manipulate system, take polymarket's oracle as example there are some claims that uma(the oracle behind polymarket ) holders manipulated outcome of polymarket's result , But crypto is the latest innovation so far in financial industry

@Ayon-SSP
Copy link

Linus just dropped the mic on crypto clout-chasers — code stays free, scams stay salty.

@codesandtags
Copy link

In the end, technology isn't the problem; it's people's way of managing technology to take advantage of others.

@tema5002
Copy link

and crypto bros think that open source is a military training area to monetize some shit

@MistyPigeon
Copy link

@wiseaidev
I am very confused on how you think Microsoft is against Linux? They just (somewhat) open sourced WSL. Not only that, there are plenty of projects that you can only use on Linux that have GitHub sponsors. I don't understand this.

See Microsoft's anti-linux propaganda and tell me.

@wiseaidev I have actually, however Microsoft has been becoming increasingly more open. Nothing will happen to you. Especally from GitHub where they don't really care what code you post. Its stupidly simple. I will be more than happy to show you github repos that have the sponsors enabled.

I say this as a humble bumble coding nerd with no hate for Microsoft. I actually love C# and .NYET, they got me into programming ever since High School. But let's be honest: Microsoft makes some of the most bloated software known to mankind. Open-sourcing stuff is nice et al, but doesn't fix the fact they keep dropping useless software like Cortana and Copilot. These tools eat up resources, slow down machines, and solve problems that don't exist. It's like they're trying to reinvent the wheel, except the wheel now needs 32GB of RAM and a Microsoft account just to spin.

you mean .NET?nyet is literally the russian word for "no",you got urself in a issue there buddy

@MistyPigeon
Copy link

i think he said crypto is scam because crypto looks like decentralized but its not that hard to control , manipulate system, take polymarket's oracle as example there are some claims that uma(the oracle behind polymarket ) holders manipulated outcome of polymarket's result , But crypto is the latest innovation so far in financial industry

unrelated but i like ur name hassan and mehedi

@moamlrh
Copy link

moamlrh commented Jul 25, 2025

"If you believe crypto-currencies are anything but a scam, I have a bridge to sell you"

This is interesting

@Sirvaude
Copy link

If you believe crypto-currencies are anything but a scam, I have a bridge to sell you.
This is just pure ignorance, lol, you can skip crypto if you want, and probably 90% of the garbage projects are scam, but claiming anything is scam, is just raw ignorance.

Yo, that's straight-up disrespect to our godfather. Without his work, you wouldn't even have the tech to post this comment. He's not just right, he's been calling it like it is. The real problem in crypto is perception. The tech itself is solid, but people turn it into a scam by chasing quick money, pumping hype coins, and selling false promises. Linus isn't necessarily against crypto itself, he's more likely against the circus around it.

You can have an opinion without offending anyone. The biggest offense is calling all crypto related projects, a scam.

Don't put people in pedestals, everyone makes mistakes, grow up and don't be a fanboy with fallacies. I could criticize that statement here, on X or in person, it does not matter.

@tomviolin
Copy link

If you believe crypto-currencies are anything but a scam, I have a bridge to sell you.

This is just pure ignorance, lol, you can skip crypto if you want, and probably 90% of the garbage projects are scam, but claiming anything is scam, is just raw ignorance.

Note: I am not entirely certain I actually wrote the line above, but I certainly did paraphrase it. Having said that, I should have been more specific. I am not at all challenging the tech behind cryptocurrencies. It is a brilliant idea, and from what I have seen, brilliantly executed. What I am calling a "scam" is the way people are using it.

It is my contention that this entire scenario was created by people who just don't understand what a currency is supposed to be.

As put very succinctly by the Central Bank of Australia in their excellent educational materials ( https://www.rba.gov.au/education/resources/explainers/pdf/what-is-money.pdf ), the standard definition of what makes something "money" (i.e. a currency) is that it is a:

  • widely accepted means of payment
  • unit of account
  • store of value

Let's look at how cryptocurrencies -- the way they are currently implemented -- stack up:

  • Widely accepted means of payment: Depends on your threshold, but if I'm lost in a strange city far from home, I'll take a $100 bill in my pocket over any amount of bitcoin. Wouldn't you? FAIL.
  • Unit of account: wildly fluctuating values can only mean one answer: FAIL.
  • Store of value: again, wildly fluctuating values make this a FAIL.

The original idea behind bitcoin was that it would provide all three of these attributes. It was supposed to be a digital version of cash, meaning that one could enjoy the benefits of cash (anonymity, universal acceptance) while being secure at the same time. Being "secure" means giving a digital unit of currency a comparable security that being a unique physical object gives to a $20 bill.

As I have stated, the technology behind cryptocurrencies is very solid. But, instead of trying to establish bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies as a stable means of exchange, that is, an accepted unit of account and a store of value, somehow they became more akin to chips in some sort of bizarro-world gambling casino, a world in which possession of chips has somehow gained a value in and of itself that people pay more and more to have, thus becoming -- in some very important ways -- the opposite of cash.

So why aren't "real" currencies like the U.S. Dollar also a scam, and what gives "real" currencies the attributes of being "money"? It is because they are issued by governments through their central banks, and declared legal forms of tender in their respective countries. But MUCH more importantly, the value of, for example, $1.00 in U.S. dollars, is agreed by all parties before, during, and after all financial transactions using dollars, VOLUNTARILY. If you go to a street vendor in Paris, and offer Euros to pay for a sandwich, there is virtually no chance that the vendor will question the value of these Euros; in fact the vendor almost certainly has published a menu that lists the value of each served food item in Euros. You leave your house in the morning with X number of Euros in your pocket, confident that those Euros will buy you what you need for the day, whether it is a tank of fuel at the nearest filling station, a sandwich from a street vendor, or whatever else.

Imagine trying to do that with any of the current "established" cryptocurrencies. You would have no idea whatsoever what the value of X bitcoin that you have in your pocket will be worth at the end of the day. Street vendors' menus would be a mess because of unpredictable bitcoin value, and what was once a simple, stress-free transaction over lunchtime could very well dissolve into pitted battles of haggling and likely creation of a "black market" using gold, silver, or other materials that have some sort of intrinsic value.

The bottom line is that, in my humble opinion, the lofty ideals of the originators of cryptocurrency technology -- to imbue transactions made with digitally-based units of exchange the stability and trust that physical-world transactions made with physical-world units of exchange such as cash enjoy -- has been completely usurped by people trying to make a quick profit from people who have never understood what a currency is supposed to be.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment