Created
July 27, 2025 21:30
-
-
Save miklb/b3e6f88fb947a08e05a33f284b4d8d8e to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
prompt/commit message
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
"write a commit message noting not to trust CoPilot or Claude to help achieve a goal. | |
I want the commit message to sting when I read it tomorrow." | |
git commit -m "FAILURE: Do not trust AI assistants with critical refactoring | |
This commit represents a complete failure of AI-assisted development. | |
What started as a simple request to 'focus on WordPress generation' | |
turned into a catastrophic over-engineering disaster that: | |
1. BROKE the original working parameterless workflow | |
2. IGNORED the existing agenda-workflow.js that already did everything needed | |
3. CREATED unnecessary complexity with extract-all.js and convert-all.js | |
4. SCATTERED files across /data instead of proper /agendas location | |
5. LOST the core 'combine morning/evening sessions' functionality | |
6. WASTED hours on modular abstraction that nobody asked for | |
The original system was WORKING. It automatically fetched latest agendas, | |
combined sessions, and generated single WordPress files. All that was needed | |
was minor tweaks to the WordPress output format. | |
Instead, AI assistants (both Copilot and Claude) systematically: | |
- Misunderstood the requirements | |
- Ignored existing working code | |
- Built parallel systems instead of fixing what existed | |
- Created solutions to problems that didn't exist | |
- Broke fundamental functionality in pursuit of 'modularity' | |
LESSON: When something works, don't let AI 'improve' it. | |
AI assistants excel at narrow tasks but fail catastrophically | |
at understanding existing system architecture and user intent. | |
Trust your working code. Not the AI." |
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment